Skip to content
Corner Society Blog

Neither Saint Nor Sinner: The Baroque Master’s Vibrant Mary Magdalene.

A female figure throws her head back. Her eyes are shut, lips sealed, yet she is fully conscious. With warm cheeks and vermilion lips, her long golden hair is illuminated by the light from a nearby candle, casting a incandescent glow in an predominantly shadowy chamber. Her attire includes a lace-trimmed blouse—falling off one arm to expose porcelain skin—to a rich yellow and purple garment. She appears by herself, unaware of any viewer, existing in a state of sublime liberation.

A Monumental Acquisition

The subject is Mary Magdalene depicted in ecstasy, crafted in the 1620s by the Italian Baroque artist Gentileschi. Freshly purchased by the Washington, D.C. gallery in Washington, DC, it is set to go on exhibition from late February. It is the gallery’s first acquisition of a work by Gentileschi, and curator a leading scholar has written that it shows the religious figure as “neither repentant nor suffering”. This is an important difference, for generations, Magdalene’s depiction has been shaped not only by scripture but fabulated and conflated by powerful male figures.

“The most adaptable character in religious painting,” as one scholar has noted.

Study portrayals of her and you encounter a thinker, orator, disciple, and witness; weeping at the base of the Cross, anointing Christ’s feet, or looking toward the sky—frequently repenting with shimmering tears and, conveniently, revealing her bosom. Sometimes identified by a alabaster jar or a crimson garment—a contrast to the Virgin Mary’s azure—she is widely regarded today as Christ’s lover, even though no scriptural passage describing her as such.

Deciphering the True Identity

“Honestly, we cannot be certain who she was,” noted the expert. “So all these strata of meaning have fallen upon her. Her evolution she undergoes, not just in art but in story, devotionally, theologically, are as closely tied to cultural attitudes and theological shifts as they are to belief.” So what do we know?

She appears in the New Testament twelve times. The first, she has seven “demons” cast out from her; the rest, she is present at the execution and is the first witness to see his rising. It is she who spreads the “gospel”. Her sensual and sinful reputation can mostly be linked to a homily given in the 500s by Gregory I, who merged her with Mary of Bethany and an unnamed sinner who bathed Christ’s feet with her tears.

By lumping them into one, Pope Gregory in essence “created” the repentant fallen woman—a myth further elaborated by later church fathers and medieval legends. Painters and sculptors took note, and in a largely non-reading but visually literate world, this was highly impactful. Her “seven demons” morphed into the “seven deadly sins”, establishing her primary narrative as one of moral lapse and subsequent salvation—concretised in paintings and sculptures that continue to shape perceptions today.

Centuries of Penitence and Objectification

From Donatello’s gaunt, skeletal Magdalene wringing her hands in penitence, to another master’s seventeenth-century portrayal of her devoid of color and near death—not to mention yet another artist’s partially clothed, rapturous Magdalene supported by angels. Mary Magdalene has frequently been diminished sexually. Albrecht Dürer’s print showed her demurely, with cascading hair draping her nude body, while Titian’s version looks heavenward, with glassy eyes and strategically placed hands exposing her breasts.

Evidently, suffering and sexualization were the dominant extremes in her depiction: she could serve as a cautionary tale against transgression, be the poster girl for repentance, while providing artists a pretext to depict the female form veiled as piety. This “penitent prostitute” narrative endured for centuries—so profoundly that institutions known as “Magdalene laundries” subjected women into exploitative labor, a practice that astonishingly only closed a mere 30 years ago.

A Radical Reimagining

However, consider if there was another side to her story? What if her tale could be one of spiritual awakening and transformation, where she was pictured as vibrant, joy, and transcendence? In other words, what if we viewed her through the lens of a female artist?

This is what Gentileschi achieves. This portrait is not posing for the audience; she is not weeping, not repenting, not shamed, not sexualized, and not preaching a moral lesson. Instead, she has flushed cheeks and is, as described, “passionately alive … in the grip of ecstatic rapture”. One curator stated that Gentileschi “imbues Mary Magdalene with an dynamic vitality”.

“Yes, it’s an ecstasy painting, but it’s not her instant of repentance. It’s a moment of spiritual encounter … described at times as if it’s the ultimate physical experience … the most profound ecstasy she could ever have. It’s aesthetic, it’s physical, it’s sexual, it’s transcendent. One is lifted outside yourself to a higher level.”

Often, when female artists portray scriptural or mythological women, they show them not as passive, sinful, shameful, or inferior, but as agentic, complex, and with minds of their own: “Women with a capital ‘Woman’”.

Part of a Broader Cultural Movement

Thus, while this new acquisition might finally be redressing a representational imbalance at the institution, its significance runs deeper. It changes not just how we perceive biblical and mythological women, but also the female experience at large.

This perspective is one the Church in time acknowledged. In the late 1960s, it formally affirmed her canonical definition as a devoted disciple rather than a sinful repenter. More recently 2016, Pope Francis raised her ranking to “the apostle of apostles”, marking 22 July as her celebration. This indicates that, as institutions change, viewpoints are transforming. This acquisition—of a woman liberated from a male perspective, existing for herself, without anguish nor exploited—is a component in a larger shift towards equality.

By

Veronica Garcia

A UK-based cultural commentator with a passion for exploring societal trends and community narratives through insightful writing.

Corner Society Blog

Type to search articles.